In the digital age, accessibility is vital, yet it often takes a backseat in web design. A critical aspect of accessibility is the use of alt text for images, which serves to provide context to users who are unable to see the visual content. Writing effective alt text is essential, yet many still fall into common pitfalls that can hinder the user experience. Here, we’ll explore the most significant flaws in alt text implementation, illustrating their impact through real-life examples.
The Purpose of Alt Text
Alt text, or alternative text, describes the content of an image for users who use screen readers or for those with visual impairments. It functions not just as a descriptive tool but also ensures that important information conveyed through images is accessible. Unfortunately, poorly implemented or missing alt text can detract from a user’s understanding of the content surrounding these images.
Common Pitfalls in Alt Text Writing
1. Using Vague or Irrelevant Descriptions
One of the most egregious mistakes is utilizing vague or misleading descriptions in the alt text. For instance, an image containing crucial information—like testimonials or significant quotes—might have an alt text that is tangentially related to the image content instead of accurately transcribing the textual elements present in the image. In one example, a book on Amazon had an image showcasing a critical quote but was labeled with alt text that read "Nicholas Sparks, The Return, Christmas gifts." This alt text provided no real insight into the image, leading screen reader users to miss meaningful content.
2. Neglecting Images of Text
A significant issue arises when images of text are used without providing alternative text or transcriptions. Images containing text (such as promotional messages or critical information) should have alt text that replicates this content. Failing to do so results in a lack of accessibility, making it impossible for users who rely on assistive technologies to glean essential information.
3. Empty or Null Alt Text
While there are instances where null alt text (alt="") may be appropriate—such as decorative images where no textual representation exists—its misuse can significantly impact accessibility. An example was found where the alt text for an image of a testimonial was set to null, rendering it completely unhelpful for a user seeking that information. Although the image lacked accompanying text, users depended on a proper description to obtain context.
4. Inconsistent Contextual Information
Even when alt text is implemented, inconsistencies can arise when relevant text is not placed nearby. For example, if a testimonial appears in an image but the only text reference is located elsewhere on the page, it disrupts the flow of information for screen reader users. They might navigate the page without receiving the full context necessary to understand the content.
5. Poor Scalable Formatting
Images containing text can also present problems when large users try to zoom in for better readability. Unlike standard text, images do not scale well; they may become blurry and difficult to read as users zoom in. This can create significant barriers especially for users who have visual impairments or require larger text sizes for clarity.
Best Practices for Effective Alt Text
-
Be Descriptive and Specific: Always describe the content of the image accurately and ensure the alt text reflects the information presented within the image.
-
Avoid Images for Text: Use HTML and CSS for text-based elements instead of embedding text within an image whenever possible. This ensures that users can scale and read the content without degradation.
-
Ensure Contextual Referencing: Place relevant textual references near images and ensure alt text includes vital information whether or not that text exists elsewhere on the page.
-
Consistency and Clarity: When using testimonials or significant identifiers, ensure that they are consistently described from image to image, providing a clear, singular narrative for users relying on screen readers.
-
Regular Audits: Continuously review and audit images and their corresponding alt text to ensure accessibility standards are met and that the implementation is effective.
Conclusion
Writing effective alt text is essential in creating an inclusive digital experience. By avoiding common pitfalls such as vague descriptions, omissions in critical information, and failures in contextual placement, writers can significantly enhance the accessibility and overall user experience of their websites. As digital content developers, it is vital to prioritize this often-overlooked aspect to ensure equal access for all users, reinforcing the web as a universal medium.
